Marginalia: sacred or secular?

I hate to say it, but almost every time I see a secular person comment on religion like the above event, it's a revelation of ignorance. The reason why there are all kinds of weird and wonderful things *in the margins* or *on the edges* of medieval church architecture and fittings is because they are the fringe things. They aren't the things that should be the central focus of attention.

You will not find these things associated with the 'heart' or centre of a church building. But they exist, so they need to be portrayed, since medieval churches were intended as 'microcosms', that is, miniature representations of the entire universe.

Once this is said, the headline above looks stupid.

Medieval people could deal with sex and idiosyncratic or aberrant behaviour more sensibly than we can. Our modern focus on control and purity (especially moral) means we leave nothing alone, and therefore go a bit kooky when confronted with things that cannot be rationally explained.

The medieval world dealt with those things by putting them in the margin, and not normalising them. We, on the other hand, have no clear boundary between central things and marginal things. Sexuality, immigration, health care ... all these debates are about this very problem of inside vs outside. But because we have no central thing, nothing higher that can resolve the issue, our national political debates are never resolved.

That's why we are living in clown world, folks.

Comments

Review of "The Language of Creation" by Matthieu Pageau

The problem we face today (and the problem that nearly all my reading, thinking and writing is centred on) is how to be the Church in the face of modernism. This was a really important book for me and I hope this essay goes some way to explaining why. I will say at the outset that I am simplifying here: pre-modern conceptions of the universe have persisted in the West, but nevertheless, the general trend has been towards abandoning such perspectives, and I am concerned with the overall downward trend, not exceptions. The general problem can be called scientism, that is, that matter is all there is, and thus the scientific method defines all there is to know. This is our basic outlook, and it manifests itself in many different ways, from ideologies as a concept, to consumerism and popular culture. In this way, all metaphysics, religion, spirituality and morality are seen as not based in material reality, and therefore not real, but rather imagined: they are social constructs, complet...

My (current) map of reality

This is a highly condensed version of how my map of reality developed; much is left out, and clarity is sacrificed for a packed sentence. My journey began in a tradition that has a deep respect for scripture, especially interpreted 'materialistically' or 'literally'. While there's problems with this, it has the strength of honouring the word of God: I was never persuaded by liberalism, which thinks it knows better than the Bible. My thought has always been that if God has spoken to us through Scripture, perhaps he knows what it means and we don't always, and to hold something in contempt is to place yourself in a position where you cannot understand it. But before I get in really deep, I should explain the basic problem I had, which was essentially a feeling of cognitive dissonance with my experience of the world, knowledge of history, literature, art and science etc, and what the mainline reformed-evangelical protestant church (I will use the word '...

Review of The Ballad of Buster Scruggs

The Coen brother's Netflix film, The Ballad of Buster Scruggs, moves from the humorous to the profound, but also, as others have pointed out, from a romanticized version of passage to the afterlife to a chillingly serious one. **Spoiler warning** It is beautifully produced. All the scenes are splendidly shot and the acting is perfect. Despite being composed of six stories of varying lengths, the film coheres. The film could firstly be read as a somewhat cynical, albeit well-rounded tribute to the western genre in all its diversity, since the main characters are often anti-heros, and the stories are all haunted by tragedy: the normal order of things is often reversed. However, just as the book of Revelation refers to essentially every book of the Old Testament, but almost never with direct quotes and nearly always with modification and re-contextualization, so the Coen brothers do the same with Westerns, attempting a metareading of the genre. The effect of this technique is to rev...

The Full Creation

Search This Blog